top menu

Science

Stephen Hall is Professor of Animal Science at the University of Lincoln and a Trustee of the Chillingham Wild Cattle Association. Professor Hall writes:

The Chillingham Wild White Cattle have a unique place in the British fauna. They are one of the very few herds of cattle anywhere in the world that have a natural sex ratio and age distribution, and where there is no castration.

The cattle are included in the standard world catalogue of Iivestock breeds (Porter, 2002) and feature in the national inventory of livestock genetic resources (DEFRA, 2013).

The number of cattle in the herd fluctuates but is now relatively stable. The last major variation was the reduction to just five bulls and eight cows in the harsh winter of 1947. To try to ensure the survival of the cattle should conditions affect the herd at Chillingham, we have established a reserve herd at a secret location in Scotland.

science-1

No evidence of notifiable disease has been identified in the herd, clinically or at autopsy. The herd has never been tuberculin tested. The absence of evidence of tuberculosis, the isolation of the herd, the fact that the cattle do not enter the food chain and the likelihood that confining the herd for testing might provoke panic and possibly lead to the deaths of young animals, all argue against any imposition of a testing regime.

Since 1950, a total of 64 Chillingham cattle (about 14% of the animals born into the herd) have undergone post mortem examination, ranging from full post mortem including worm counts, culture and histology (conducted at veterinary investigation centres on entire carcasses), to field autopsy with laboratory examination of samples.

Behaviour – why study it?

In 1973 Tinbergen, Lorenz and von Frisch shared a Nobel Prize for their experimental behavioural work and today animal behaviour is every bit as rigorous and scientific as any other branch of biology. It tells us about evolution, and provides underpinning for animal welfare studies.

Back in the 1970s it was thought that studying cattle in a free-living state to discover their natural behaviours would help with improving their welfare on farms. This approach has certainly worked with pigs where work on free-ranging and wild herds has been crucially important in designing housing systems and herd management procedures. But life for the Chillingham cattle is so radically different from that of, say, veal calves or dairy cows or feedlot bulls that it’s hard to draw any conclusions relevant to welfare.

However, behavioural comparisons of Chillingham cows and bulls have told us a lot about the general zoology of large mammals. This is knowledge of interest in its own right and helps us to understand how to manage and conserve the herd.

It’s easy to forget that in her life a normal cow – whether on a farm or at Chillingham – will only show sexual behaviour maybe 4 or 5 times. Each time she gets pregnant her next period of receptivity will be at least a month after she calves. But with year-round breeding, bulls may have mating opportunities at any time. This is quite unlike what happens in animals like red deer that have a seasonal rut when the males only show sexual behaviour during a couple of months. So the whole structure of bull behaviour at Chillingham is different – both from the cows, and from almost all other large wild mammals.

This shows in their everyday behaviour. Timing with a stopwatch, for instance, how long a bull spends munching at a patch of grass you can see that bulls have shorter daytime bouts of most of what we call maintenance behaviours – grazing, rubbing against an object, lying, walking – while these bouts are longer at night.

It adds up to a picture of the bulls being more distractible than cows and this is presumably because they have to be constantly on the alert for cows coming into heat, and for rival bulls.

Cows have quite a complex social system based on pairwise relationships between individuals – the basic building block of the herd may be a mother/daughter bond but this hasn’t been confirmed. It could equally well be the links between the females born in a particular year. But bulls have a simple pecking order when they are forced into the same area.

This used to happen during hay feeding, but in the interests of protecting little calves we don’t feed them that way any more. The rest of the time they tend to live in groups with others of the same age, and certainly when numbers were lower than they are today each of these cliques shared a particular home range in the park and no one bull had complete freedom to range over the whole area – though the main herd, comprising cows and calves and young bulls – did.

Now that numbers have become quite high this picture has become very muddled. Especially because as numbers have risen the sex ratio of the herd has changed. There used to be, in most years, many more females than males (equal numbers of male and female calves are born) but when conditions are favourable – as they seem to be, currently – survival rates of males of all ages are much better.

Here is a list of publications relevant to the Chillingham herd:

Chillingham Cattle: an academic bibliography

Stephen J.G. Hall MA PhD

(Emeritus Professor of Animal Science, University of Lincoln)

Livestock Diversity Ltd.

3 Cross O’Cliff Hill, Lincoln LN5 8PN, UK

sthall@lincoln.ac.uk

April 2016

 

Introduction

 

During the 19th century the Chillingham cattle began to attract considerable academic interest. First brought to popular notice by Thomas Bewick (Uglow, 2006) and to the attention of agriculturists by Bailey and Culley (1794), the herd was mentioned by Darwin (1868) in the contexts of behaviour and inbreeding. The cattle, and those of other parks, were also mentioned in zoological texts such as Harting (1880) and in a special report for the British Association for the Advancement of Science (Hughes, 1887). Whitehead (1953) updated Storer (1877) to produce the most authoritative account of the history of the herds of parkland white cattle in Britain, though both accounts are uncritical in many important respects.

 

In recent years genetic techniques have been applied to the cattle which will cast light on their origins and their relationships with other breeds. Skeletal material has contributed to the development of zooarchaeology. Veterinary investigations are of relevance not only to the health and welfare of the cattle, but can also contribute to the development of animal science. Chillingham Park, as a designed landscape that was probably developed from medieval wood pasture has attracted attention as a subject of study in its own right.

 

This earlier secondary material is not reviewed exhaustively in the present bibliography which concentrates upon reports that describe or summarise original scientific or historical work on the cattle and on Chillingham Park. Material on the family of the Earls of Tankerville, former owners of the herd, is included if broadly relevant. Papers, books and chapters where the Chillingham cattle were not the prime topic are also included, if this is where material unobtainable elsewhere is to be found. This bibliography will be updated periodically.

 

Bibliography in chronological order

 

·         Shirley (1867)

Catalogue of British deer parks, with passing mention of Chillingham.

·         Bateman (1883)

The Tankerville estates in historical context; total area in Northumberland was 28,930 acres (and 2,493 acres in Shropshire).

·         Hughes (1887)

Descriptive report prepared for British Association on the “wild white cattle” of Chartley, Chillingham, Lyme, Cadzow, Somerford, Middleton and Vaynol, no inferences being drawn as to their origin.

·         Hodgson (1916)

Further historical background on Tankerville estates.

·         Dodds (1935)

Succinct, authoritative account of history of Chillingham Park and the neighbourhood referring to original sources. Reproduces important estate map. Essential background reading for anyone investigating Chillingham history.

·         Tankerville (1956)

General account, reference to herd sharing Park with “nine score” South Country Cheviot ewes.

·         Bilton (1957)

Includes original work on skull anatomy, derived from work on specimens in Natural History Museum, London, showing affinities of Chillingham cattle with present-day breeds.

·         Hodgson (1967)

Critical reappraisal of 1916 investigations at Corstopitum (Hadrian’s Wall), which had led to the unjustified assertion of a Roman influence on the cattle of the region.

·         Pearson (1968)

Comments on widespread occurrence of cattle breeds with similar coloration to that of Chillingham cattle. Concludes coloration cannot be a reliable indicator of breed affinity, suggests “a study of blood characteristics may offer the most promising direction for future research”.

·         Lancaster and Hong (1971)

Parasitological study. No new species were found.

·         Gilbert (1972)

Study of lichens in Chillingham Park. Little of any interest found.

·         Grigson (1974)

Craniology of Chillingham cattle (specimens gathered during 19th century and mid-20th century), in relation to that of other breeds.

·         Bennet (1979)

The only publication by Hon. Ian Bennet who was intimately involved with management of the herd from the 1960s until his death in 1998. Includes useful material on management.

·         Davies and Turner (1979)

Pollen analysis from sites including the moors above and to the east of Chillingham Park.

·         Hall (1979)

Account of fieldwork in progress at Chillingham; a field study conducted full time from 1977 to 1980. Includes first account of home range behaviour of bulls.

·         Armitage (1982); Clutton-Brock (1982);Grigson (1982)

Important papers on body dimensions of British cattle from the prehistoric aurochs and early domesticated cattle, to the improved breeds of the 18th century. Chillingham not mentioned, but these studies are of prime significance for formulating hypotheses on their origin and breed affinities.

·         Hall (1983)

Abstract of conference paper on work in progress. Superseded by Hall (1989b).

·         Hall and Bunce (1984)

Vegetation survey of the Park, conducted in 1979. An early example of indicator species analysis, a popular multivariate statistical approach to characterising plant communities.

·         Hall (1985)

Transcript of conference paper on work in progress. Reports unpublished data of Dr. R.R. Ashdown on testicular hypoplasia of bulls, and data on body weights and horn lengths.

·         Hall and Moore (1986)

Comparisons are drawn with the Chillingham herd in this account of feral cattle on the Orkney island of Swona.

·         Hall (1986)

Four year study on social interactions during hay feeding. Bulls have a simple hierarchy that changes from winter to winter, while cows have more complex and stable social structure.

·         Rackham (1986)

Brief mentions of Chillingham and other park herds, with important critical insights on history.

·         Hall (1988)

Application of results of Hall and Bunce (1984) to interpreting movement of cattle around Park. Probably first direct application of vegetation ordination to understanding the ecology of mammals.

·         Hall and Clutton-Brock (1988)

Chapters on Chillingham and on White Park cattle.

·         Hall and Hall (1988)

Reports blood group results gathered over several years which indicated marked genetic uniformity in the herd, together with no obvious affinity to any other breed. Investigation of key mortality and fecundity factors, with reference to data gathered in the 19th and 20th centuries. Evidently, viability of herd had not declined since then, in spite of inbreeding.

·         Hall et al. (1988)

Behavioural and sonagraphic study of vocalisations. Previously unreported diversity of bull vocalisations interpreted in terms of social context.

·         Hall (1989a)

Update of Hall (1979) with further historical material.

·         Hall (1989b)

Ethological study on fine structure of behaviour with comparisons between the sexes. Using vegetation results of Hall and Bunce (1984), interprets grazing behaviour in terms of a measure of sward quality.

·         Hall (1989c)

Synoptic review of herd and park.

·         Schwabe and Hall (1989)

Includes material on calving mortality.

·         Hall (1991)

General account including material not published elsewhere on body weights and diseases.

·         Hall (1992)

Report of first steps of landscape repair in Chillingham Park by the new owners.

·         Ritvo (1992)

Sociological perspective on the Victorian interest in the Chillingham cattle.

·         Beasley et al. (1993)

Osteological study of Chillingham and other cattle, for application in archaeology.

·         Jessop and Boyd (1996)

Discusses source of text and illustrations published by Thomas Bewick.

·         Yalden (1999)

Includes brief resumé of Chillingham herd in context of mammal fauna of Britain

·         Brownlie (2001)

Mentions Chillingham herd briefly, in context of discussion on policy towards genetic resources threatened by foot-and-mouth disease.

·         Visscher et al. (2001)

Reports remarkably high level of microsatellite homozygosity. Updates Hall and Hall (1988) and suggests slow inbreeding has purged harmful recessives from the Chillingham cattle.

·         Defra (2002)

Inventory of UK breeds, includes Chillingham.

·         Hemming (2002)

Critical review of accounts from British and Irish folklore, of cultural importance of red-eared white cattle.

·         Ingham (2002)

Reports congenital malformation of dentition.

·         Landscapes  and Gardens, University of York (2002)

Entry of Chillingham Park and the Castle gardens in database.

·         Porter (2002)

Fifth edition of this definitive inventory of breed names.

·         Schama (2002)

Bewick’s woodcut of the Chillingham bull is described as “an image of massive power … the great, perhaps the greatest icon of British natural history, and one loaded with moral, national and historical sentiment as well as purely zoological fascination”

·         Alderson (2003)

Cites Chillingham cattle in context of developing prioritisation protocols.

·         Gaillard and Yoccoz (2003)

In the course of a review of population dynamics, reports intrinsic rate of increase of Chillingham cattle as (lambda) 1.06 which is broadly similar to what is seen in other large herbivores.

·         Ingham (2003)

Succinct account of herd history.

·         Hall (2004)

Reference to Chillingham cattle in context of new method of prioritising breeds for conservation.

·         JNCC (2004)

Status of parkland and wood pasture in Britain and Habitat Action Plan.

·         Countryside Agency (2005)

Landscape character of Chillingham area.

·         Hall et al. (2005)

Review, in the state veterinary service journal, of how management of the herd is reconciled with veterinary and legal requirements.

·         Ingham (2005)

Report of a Chillingham calf, born without a tail.

·         Hall (2006)

Update of Hall (1989c), with particular reference to the policy environment.

·         Hall (2007)

Preliminary outline of history of Chillingham Park, mainly deals with late 18th century remodelling of pre-existing park.

·         Hall and Putman (2008)

Updates Hall (1991) and includes comparative material on extensively husbanded cattle elsewhere.

·         Hall (2010)

History of Chillingham Park, mainly deals with late 18th century remodelling of pre-existing park, with reference to national and regional trends.

·         McGowan (2010)

Conservation management plan prepared with support from Natural England, not yet publicly available.

·         Burthe et al. (2011)

Reports possible effect of climate change on timing of breeding in the Chillingham herd.

·         Fletcher (2011)

General history of deer parks with passing references to Chillingham.

·         Hall and Bunce (2011)

Description of tree population of Chillingham Park.

·         Ballingall et al. (2012)

Report of remarkable degree of genetic uniformity within immune system of Chillingham cattle.

·         Defra (2013)

Inventory and census of UK breeds, includes Chillingham.

·         Hall (2012)

General account of history, biology and management.

·         Hindmarch and Hall (2012)

General review in context of European pastoralist systems.

·         Hudson et al. (2012)

Mitochondrial DNA genotype of Chillingham cattle.

·         Brenig et al. (2013)

Genetic mechanism of coat coloration in some British white breeds, possibly similar to situation in Chillingham cattle, though this is yet to be studied formally.

·         Bunce and Hall (2013)

Comparison of vegetation of Park in 1979 and in 2008.

·         Hall (2013)

History of Chillingham Park with particular reference to trees, and relevance to wood-pasture conservation and management.

·         Ritvo (2013)

Development of ideas presented by Ritvo (1992).

·         Ellis and Hammond (2014)

Report of remarkable degree of genetic uniformity within immune system of Chillingham cattle.

·         Towers et al. (2014, 2016)

Isotopic composition of Chillingham teeth studied in relation to seasonality of birth and in relation to archaeological methodologies relating to prehistoric dairying.

·         Orozco-terWengel et al. (2015)

Paper comparing SNP genotype of Chillingham cattle with those of other breeds.

·         Williams et al. (2015)

Report of SNP genotype of Chillingham cattle with emphasis on extreme homozygosity.

·         van Asperen et al. (2016)

Study of fungal spores in dung of Chillingham cattle in development of palaeoecological methodologies.

Reference List

Alderson, L. (2003) Criteria for the recognition and prioritization of breeds of special genetic importance. Animal Genetic Resources Information 33, 1-9.

Armitage, P.L. (1982) Developments in British cattle husbandry from the Romano-British period to early modern times. Ark 9, 50-54.

Bailey, J., and Culley, G. (1794) General view of the agriculture of the county of Northumberland with observations on the means of its improvement. Board of Agriculture, London.

Ballingall, K.T., Steele, P., and Hall,S.J.G. (2012) A complete lack of functional MHC diversity within an apparently healthy population of large mammals. Immunology, 137, 69.

Bateman, J. (1883) The great landowners of Great Britain and Ireland. Reprinted 1971, Leicester University Press.

Beasley, M.J., Brown, W.A.B., and Legge, A.J. (1993) Metrical discrimination between mandibular first and second molars in domestic cattle. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 3, 303-314.

Bennet, I. (1979) The challenge of Chillingham Park. Roebuck. Journal of the Northumberland Wildlife Trust 26, 13-18.

Bilton, L. (1957) The Chillingham herd of wild cattle. Transactions of the Natural History Society of Northumberland, Durham and Newcastle upon Tyne 12, 137-160.

Brenig, B., Beck, J., Floren, C., Bornemann-Kolatzki, K., Wiedemann, I., Hennecke ,S., Swalve, H.H., and Schutz, E. (2013) Molecular genetics of coat colour variations in White Galloway and White Park cattle. Animal Genetics, 44, 450-453.

Brownlie, J. (2001) Strategic decisions to evaluate before implementing a vaccine programme in the face of a foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) outbreak. Veterinary Record 148, 358-360.

Bunce, R.G.H., and Hall, S.J.G. (2013) Vegetation change from 1979 to 2008 at Chillingham Park in relation to conservation of the Chillingham Wild Cattle. Northumbrian Naturalist (Transactions of the Natural History Society of Northumbria), 75, 18-30.

Burthe, S., Butler, A., Searle, K.R., Hall, S.J.G., and Thackeray, S.J. (2011) Demographic consequences of increased winter births in a large aseasonally breeding mammal (Bos taurus L.) in response to climate change. Journal of Animal Ecology, 80, 1134-1144.

Clutton-Brock, J. (1982) British cattle in the 18th century. Ark 9, 55-59.

Countryside Agency (2005). 2. Northumberland Sandstone Hills. www.countryside.gov.uk/LAR/Landscape/CC/north_east/northumberland_sandstone_hills.asp

Darwin, C. (1868) The variation of animals and plants under domestication. Vols. I and II. Popular edition, 1905, John Murray, London.

Davies, G., and Turner, J. (1979) Pollen diagrams from Northumberland. New Phytologist 82, 783-804.

DEFRA (2002) UK country report on farm animal genetic resources 2002, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London.

DEFRA (2013) UK country report on farm animal genetic resources 2012 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-country-report-on-farm-animal-genetic-resources-2012. Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London.

Dodds, M.H. (1935) Chillingham parish. Area and population. In A history of Northumberland (Victoria County History) Vol. XIV (ed. by M.H. Dodds), pp.301-306. Andrew Reid, Newcastle upon Tyne.

Ellis, S.A., and Hammond, J.A. (2014) The functional significance of cattle major histocompatibility complex Class I genetic diversity. Annual Review of Animal Biosciences, 2, 285-306.

Fletcher, T.J. (2011) Gardens of earthly delight. The history of deer parks. Windgather Press, Oxford.

Gaillard, J.-M., and Yoccoz, N.G. (2003) Temporal variation in survival of mammals: a case of environmental canalization? Ecology 84, 3294-3306.

Gilbert, O.L. (1972) Field meeting in Northumberland. Lichenologist 5, 337-341.

Grigson, C. (1974) The craniology and relationships of four species of Bos 1. Basic craniology: Bos taurus L. and its absolute size. Journal of Archaeological Science 1, 353-379.

Grigson, C. (1982) Cattle in prehistoric Britain. Ark 9, 47-49.

Hall,  S.J.G. (1979) Studying the Chillingham wild cattle. Ark 6, 72-79.

Hall, S.J.G. (1983) Grazing behaviour of Chillingham cattle. Applied Animal Ethology 9, 96-97.

Hall, S.J.G. (1985) The Chillingham white cattle. British Cattle Breeders Club Digest 40, 24-28.

Hall, S.J.G. (1986) Chillingham cattle: dominance and affinities and access to supplementary food. Ethology 71, 201-215 DOI:10.1111/j.1439-0310.1986.tb00584.x

Hall, S.J.G. (1988) Chillingham Park and its herd of white cattle: relationships between vegetation classes and patterns of range use. Journal of Applied Ecology 25, 777-789. DOI:10.2307/2403745

Hall, S.J.G. (1989a) Running wild. Parts 1 and 2. Ark 16, 12-15, 46-49.

Hall, S.J.G. (1989b) Chillingham cattle: social and maintenance behaviour in an ungulate which breeds all year round. Animal Behaviour 38, 215-225. DOI:10.1016/S0003-3472(89)80084-3

Hall, S.J.G. (1989c) The white herd of Chillingham. Journal of the Royal Agricultural Society of England 150, 112-119.

Hall, S.J.G. (1991) Park cattle. In The handbook of British mammals. Third edition (ed. by G.B. Corbet and S. Harris), pp.538-541. Mammal Society and Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford.

Hall, S.J.G. (1992) Caring for Chillingham Park. Ark 19, 369.

Hall, S.J.G. (2004) Conserving animal genetic resources: making priority lists of British and Irish livestock breeds. In Farm animal genetic resources (ed. by G. Simm, B. Villanueva, K.D. Sinclair and S. Townsend), pp. 311-320. Nottingham University Press, Nottingham.

Hall, S.J.G. (2006) Chillingham Park and its wild white cattle. Journal of the Royal Agricultural Society of England 167, 40-48.

Hall, S. J. G. (2007) Chillingham wild cattle park, Northumberland. Landscape Archaeology and Ecology 6 (The history, ecology and archaeology of medieval parks and parklands. ed. by I.D. Rotherham), pp. 53-57.

Hall, S. J. G. (2010) Caring for the legend of the wild bull: an interpretation of the Georgian landscape of Chillingham Park, Northumberland. Garden History 38, 213-230. DOI:10.2307/41411755.

Hall, S.J.G. (2012) Chillingham cattle Bos taurus. In Mammals, amphibians and reptiles of the north east. Northumbrian Naturalist 13, (ed. by I. Bond), pp. 60-62. Natural History Society of Northumbria.

Hall, S.J.G. (2013) Integrated conservation of a park and its associated cattle herd. Chillingham Park, northern England. In Trees, forested landscapes and grazing animals (ed. I. D. Rotherham), pp. 242-254. Routledge, London and New York.

Hall, S.J.G., and Bunce, R.G.H. (1984) Vegetation survey of Chillingham Park, Northumberland. Transactions of the Natural History Society of Northumbria 52, 5-14.

Hall,S.J.G., and Bunce,R.G.H. (2011) Mature trees as keystone structures in Holarctic ecosystems – a quantitative species comparison in a northern English park. Plant Ecology and Diversity, 4, 243-250. DOI:10.1080/17550874.2011.586735

Hall, S.J.G., and Clutton-Brock, J. (1988) Two hundred years of British farm livestock. British Museum (Natural History), London, UK.

Hall, S.J.G., Fletcher, T.J., Gidlow, J.R., Ingham, B., Shepherd, A., Smith, A., and Widdows, A. (2005) Management of the Chillingham wild cattle. Government Veterinary Journal 15, 4-11.

Hall, S.J.G., and Hall, J.G. (1988) Inbreeding and population dynamics of the Chillingham cattle (Bos taurus). Journal of Zoology, London 216, 479-493. DOI:10.1111/j.1469-7998.1988.tb02444.x

Hall, S.J.G., and Moore, G.F. (1986). Feral cattle of Swona, Orkney Islands. Mammal Review 16, 89-96. DOI:10.1111/j.1365-2907.1986.tb00026.x

Hall, S.J.G., and Putman, R.J. (2008) Cattle Bos taurus. In Mammals of the British Isles: Handbook, 4th edition (ed. by S. Harris and D.W. Yalden), pp.634-637. The Mammal Society, Southampton, UK.

Hall, S.J.G., Vince, M. A., Walser, E. S., and Garson, P. J. (1988) Vocalisations of the Chillingham cattle. Behaviour 104, 78-104. DOI:10.1163/156853988X00610

Harting, J.E. (1880) British animals extinct within historic times. With some account of British wild cattle. Trübner, London.

Hemming, J. (2002) Bos primigenius in Britain: or, why do fairy cows have red ears? Folklore 113, 71-82.

Hindmarch, C., and Hall, S.J.G. (2012) The Chillingham wild cattle of Northumberland: an evolutionary puzzle and a challenge for pastoralism. La Cañada. Newsletter of the European Forum on Nature Conservation and Pastoralism, no.29, 5.

Hodgson, G.W.I. (1967) A comparative analysis of faunal remains from some Roman and native sites in northern England http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/9667/2/9667_6456-vol2.PDF MSc thesis, Durham University.

Hodgson, J.C. (1916). The dismemberment of the Tankerville estates. History of the Berwickshire Naturalists’ Club, 22, 303-313.

Hudson, G., Wilson, I., Payne, B.I.A., Elson, J., Samuels, D.C., Santibanez-Korev, M., Hall, S.J.G., and Chinnery,P.F. (2012) Unique mitochondrial DA in highly inbred feral cattle. Mitochondrion,  12, 438-440. DOI:10.1016/j.mito.2012.05.003

Hughes, W. R. (1887). Report of the Committee, consisting of Mr. E Bidwell, Professor Boyd Dawkins, Professor Bridge, Mr. A.H. Cocks, Mr. E. de Hamel, Mr. J.E. Harting, Professor Milnes Marshall, Dr. Muirhead, Dr. Sclater, Canon Tristram, and Mr. W.R. Hughes (Secretary), appointed for the purpose of preparing a report on the herds of wild cattle in Chartley Park, and other parks in Great Britain. Report of the fifty-seventh meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science held at Manchester in August and September 1887 , pp. 135-145. 1887. London, John Murray. https://ia801407.us.archive.org/22/items/reportofbritisha88brit/reportofbritisha88brit_bw.pdf.

Ingham, B. (2002) Dental anomalies in the Chillingham Wild White Cattle. Transactions of the Natural History Society of Northumbria 62, 169-175.

Ingham, B. (2003) The Chillingham wild white cattle. Veterinary History NS 12, 11-22.

Ingham, B. (2005) Taillessness (anury) in a Chillingham Wild White calf. Transactions of the Natural History Society of Northumbria 64, 169-172.

Jessop, L., and Boyd, M.J. (1996) Some sources for Thomas Bewick’s work on the Chillingham “wild” cattle. Transactions of the Natural History Society of Northumbria 57, 21-34.

JNCC (2004). Habitat action plan. Lowland wood-pasture and parkland. http://www.ukbap.org.uk/UKPlans.aspx?ID=5. Joint Nature Conservation Committee

Lancaster, M.B., and Hong, C. (1971) The nematode fauna of the Chillingham wild white cattle.  British Veterinary Journal 127, 113-117.

Landscapes and Gardens, University of York (2002). United Kingdom database of historic parks and gardens. http://www.gardenhistory.org.uk/ukpg/place.asp?PlaceID=CHILLIN1

McGowan, P. (2010) Chillingham parkland plan. Unpublished final report, May 2010. Commissioned by Chillingham Wild Cattle Association and Natural England.

Orozco-terWengel, P., Barbato, M., Nicolazzi, E.L., Biscarini, F., Milanesi, E., Davies, W., Williams, D., Stella, A., Ajmone-Marsan, P., and Bruford,M.W. (2015) Revisiting demographic processes in cattle with genome-wide population genetics analysis. Frontiers in Genetics, 6, 191. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2015.00191

Pearson, L. (1968) A note on the history of black-eared white cattle. Agricultural History Review 16, 159-160. http://www.bahs.org.uk/16n2a6.pdf

Porter, V. (2002) Mason’s world dictionary of livestock breeds, types and varieties. 5th edition. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, UK.

Rackham, O. (1986) The history of the countryside. Dent/Phoenix Press, London.

Ritvo, H. (1992) Race, breed and myths of origin: Chillingham cattle as ancient Britons. Representations 39, 1-22.

Ritvo, H. (2013) Edging into the wild. In Beardsley, J. (ed.) Designing wildlife habitats.  Dumbarton Oaks Colloquium Series in the History of Landscape Architecture 34, pp. 15-27.

Schama, S. (2002) A history of Britain, The fate of empire 1776-2000. BBC Worldwide, London.

Schwabe, A.E., and Hall, S.J.G. (1989) Dystocia in nine British breeds of cattle and its relationship to the dimensions of the dam and calf. Veterinary Record 125, 636-639. DOI:10.1136/vr.125.26-27.636

Shirley, E.P. (1867) Some account of English deer parks: with notes on the management of deer. John Murray (and Legacy Reprint Series, Kessinger Publishing), London.

Storer, J. (1877) The wild white cattle of Great Britain. Cassell, Petter and Gilpin, London.

Tankerville, Earl of (1956) The wild white cattle of Chillingham. Agriculture 63, 176-179.

Towers, J., Gledhill, A., Bond, J., and Montgomery, J. (2014) An investigation of cattle birth seasonality using δ13C and δ18O profiles within first molar enamel. Archaeometry 56, 208-236.

Towers, J., Mainland,I., Montgomery,J. Bond, J. (2016) Calving seasonality at Pool, Orkney during the first millennium AD: an investigation using intra-tooth isotope ratio analysis of cattle molar enamel. Environmental Archaeology (online), 1-16 DOI:10.1080/14614103.2015.1116214

Uglow, J. (2006) Nature’s engraver. A life of Thomas Bewick. Faber and Faber, London.

van Asperen, E.N., Kirby, J.R., Hunt, C.O. (2016) The effect of preparation methods on dung fungal spores: Implications for recognition of megafaunal populations. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 229, 1-8.

Visscher, P.M., Smith, D., Hall, S.J.G., and Williams, J.L. (2001) A viable herd of genetically uniform cattle. Nature 409, 303. DOI:10.1038/35053160 https://www.era.lib.ed.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/1842/690/Visscher_P.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y

Whitehead, G.K. (1953) The ancient white cattle of Britain and their descendants. Faber and Faber, London.

Williams, J.L., Hall, S.J.G., Del Corvo, M., Ballingall, K.T., Colli, L., Ajmone-Marsan, P., and Biscarini, F. (2015) Inbreeding and purging at the genomic level: the Chillingham cattle reveal extensive, non-random SNP heterozygosity. Animal Genetics 47:19-27.

Yalden, D.W. (1999) The history of British mammals. T. and A.D. Poyser, London.